“Oil” is a play in need of refining

Why is it so hard to make good drama out of environmental issues?

By Robert Butler

Theatre was far too slow to address urgent environmental themes. But the last few years have seen a rapidly expanding canon. In London alone we’ve had “The Contingency Plan” (2009) at the Bush; “Greenland” (2011) at the National Theatre; “The Heretic” (2011), “Ten Billion” (2012) and “2071” (2014) at the Royal Court. The problem faced by playwrights is how to move the vastly complex environmental entanglements between the human and non-human world to centre-stage, and give them the same imaginative force as conventional dramas that focus solely on human relationships. Only Steve Waters’s “The Contingency Plan” displayed zip and zest, with characters fully immersed in the dilemmas which faced them.

The challenge is especially pronounced for Ella Hickson, the writer of a new play called “Oil”. This fossil fuel has given us – among other things – petrol, fertilisers, plastic bags, aspirin, chewing gum, lipstick and Deepwater Horizon. How do you find an angle on a substance whose most salient feature is ubiquity?

More from 1843 magazine

1843 magazine | It began as a rewilding experiment. Now a bear is on trial for murder

The death of a jogger in the Italian Alps has sparked a furious debate about the relationship between humans and nature

1843 magazine | “We have to make Biden lose”: Arab-Americans are switching to Trump

Anger over Gaza in the swing state of Michigan might cost the president the election


1843 magazine | Inside the Kenyan cult that starved itself to death

During covid-19 a preacher lured thousands of people into a remote forest. Then he told them to stop eating